Call Us Today
334.737.3718

What is the Key to a Successful Criminal Appeal in Alabama?

What is the Key to a Successful Criminal Appeal in Alabama?

What is the Key to a Successful Criminal Appeal in Alabama?

The criminal appeals process in Alabama offers hope for those facing a conviction who believe they’ve been wrongfully convicted or that significant errors occurred during their trial. To initiate an appeal, defendants must file a written notice of appeal within 14 days of sentencing or denial of a post-trial motion, whichever is later. The appeal can be for a trial de novo in the circuit court or to the Court of Criminal Appeals, depending on the circumstances. The Court of Criminal Appeals hears all appeals of felony and misdemeanor cases, including violations of city ordinances and all post-conviction writs in criminal cases.

Criminal Appeals in Alabama

What is a Criminal Appeal?

A criminal appeal is a legal process where a higher court reviews the decision made by a lower court in a criminal case. In Alabama, most criminal appeals start with the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals, with the possibility of further review by the Alabama Supreme Court. The appeals process is not about retrying the case or presenting new evidence, but rather examining the original trial for legal errors that may have affected the outcome.

Grounds for Appeal

Not every unfavorable verdict can be appealed. There must be specific legal grounds for challenging the conviction. Common grounds for appeal in Alabama include:

  • Legal errors during the trial: This could involve incorrect rulings on objections, improper admission or exclusion of evidence, or mistakes in jury instructions.
  • Ineffective assistance of counsel: If your trial attorney’s performance fell below an objective standard of reasonableness and prejudiced your case.
  • Insufficient evidence to support the conviction: When the evidence presented at trial, even when viewed in the light most favorable to the prosecution, is not enough to support a finding of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
  • Constitutional violations: Such as violations of your Fourth Amendment rights against unreasonable searches and seizures, or Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination.
  • Newly discovered evidence: In some cases, if new evidence comes to light that could have changed the outcome of the trial, it may be grounds for appeal.
  • Prosecutorial misconduct: If the prosecutor engaged in improper behavior that prejudiced your right to a fair trial.
  • Juror misconduct: If there’s evidence that jurors engaged in improper conduct that affected the verdict.

Remember, an appeal is not a new trial. Instead, it’s a review of the original trial proceedings to determine if legal errors occurred that significantly affected the outcome. The appellate court generally won’t consider new evidence or re-evaluate witness credibility unless there are exceptional circumstances.

The Alabama Criminal Appeals Process: A Step-by-Step Guide

❖ Filing the Notice of Appeal

The first and most critical step in the appeals process is filing a Notice of Appeal. In Alabama, this must typically be done within 42 days of the sentencing or the denial of a post-trial motion. This deadline is strict, and missing it can result in losing your right to appeal, so timely action is absolutely critical.

❖ Obtaining the Trial Record

Once the Notice of Appeal is filed, your appellate attorney will need to obtain a complete record of the trial proceedings. This includes transcripts of all hearings and the trial itself, all exhibits introduced into evidence, and all orders issued by the trial court. This process can take several weeks or even months, depending on the case’s complexity and the court reporter’s workload.

❖ Writing the Appellate Brief

The appellate brief is arguably the most crucial document in your appeal. It outlines your arguments for why the conviction should be overturned and requires in-depth legal research, meticulous analysis of the trial record, and persuasive writing skills. Your attorney will typically have 70 days from the date the record is complete to file this brief.

The appellate brief must adhere to strict formatting rules and typically includes:

  • A statement of the case, outlining the procedural history.
  • A statement of the facts, presenting the relevant facts from the trial record.
  • A statement of the issues, clearly defining the legal questions for the court to consider.
  • An argument section, presenting your legal arguments with citations to relevant case law and statutes.
  • A conclusion, summarizing your arguments and stating the relief you’re seeking.
❖ The State’s Response

After your brief is filed, the Alabama Attorney General’s office will have the opportunity to file a response brief. This brief will argue why the conviction should be upheld, addressing each of the arguments raised in your appellate brief.

❖ Reply Brief

In most cases, you’ll have the opportunity to file a reply brief, responding to the arguments made in the state’s brief. This is your last chance to address any points raised by the state and reinforce your arguments.

❖ Oral Arguments (if granted)

In some cases, the Court of Criminal Appeals may grant oral arguments. This allows attorneys from both sides to present their case directly to the judges and answer any questions the judges may have. Not all cases are granted oral arguments, and the court may decide the case based solely on the written briefs.

❖ The Court’s Decision

After reviewing all materials and hearing arguments (if applicable), the Court of Criminal Appeals will issue a written decision. This process can take several months or even over a year in complex cases. The court may affirm the conviction, reverse it, or remand the case back to the trial court for further proceedings.

Common Challenges in Alabama Criminal Appeals

❖ Limited Scope of Review

One of the biggest challenges in criminal appeals is the limited scope of review. The appellate court generally won’t consider new evidence or re-evaluate witness credibility. Instead, they focus on legal errors that may have occurred during the trial. This means that even if you have new evidence that proves your innocence, it might not be considered in a direct appeal (although it could potentially be grounds for a separate post-conviction relief petition).

❖ Strict Procedural Rules

Alabama’s appellate process involves numerous strict deadlines and procedural rules. Missing a deadline or failing to properly preserve an issue for appeal can be detrimental to your case. For example, if your trial attorney didn’t object to an error during the trial, the appellate court may consider that issue “waived” and refuse to consider it on appeal.

❖ “Harmless Error” Doctrine

Even if a legal error is identified, the appellate court may deem it “harmless” if they believe it didn’t significantly impact the trial’s outcome. Overcoming this hurdle requires skilled legal argumentation to demonstrate how the error affected your substantial rights or the fairness of the proceedings.

❖ Deference to Trial Court Decisions

Appellate courts often give considerable deference to the decisions made by the trial court, especially on matters involving the admissibility of evidence or the credibility of witnesses. This means that even if the appellate court might have ruled differently, they may not overturn the trial court’s decision unless it was clearly erroneous or an abuse of discretion.

Tips for Strengthening Your Alabama Criminal Appeal

❖ Preserve Issues for Appeal

Many potential appellate issues must be properly objected to or raised during the trial to be considered on appeal. Working with an experienced trial attorney who understands appellate law can help ensure important issues are preserved. If you’re already past the trial stage, your appellate attorney will need to carefully review the record to identify any preserved issues.

❖ Thoroughly Review the Trial Record

A meticulous review of the trial record is essential for identifying potential errors or constitutional violations that could form the basis of a strong appeal. This includes not just the trial transcript, but also all pre-trial and post-trial motions, jury instructions, and exhibits.

❖ Focus on Significant Legal Issues

While you may feel many things went wrong during your trial, it’s important to focus your appeal on the most significant legal issues that have the best chance of success. Presenting too many weak arguments can dilute the strength of your stronger arguments.

❖ Craft Compelling Legal Arguments

Success on appeal often comes down to the strength of your legal arguments. This requires not just identifying errors, but explaining why they matter in the context of your case and the broader legal landscape. Your arguments should be well-researched, logically structured, and supported by relevant case law and statutes.

❖ Consider All Post-Conviction Options

In addition to direct appeals, Alabama offers other post-conviction remedies like Rule 32 petitions. These can be used to raise issues such as ineffective assistance of counsel or newly discovered evidence that might not be appropriate for a direct appeal. Your attorney can help determine the best approach for your specific case.

Understanding the Role of Appellate Courts in Alabama

❖ The Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals

This is the intermediate appellate court that handles most criminal appeals in Alabama. It consists of five judges who review cases for errors of law or procedure. The court doesn’t retry cases or hear new evidence but instead focuses on whether legal errors occurred during the original trial.

❖ The Alabama Supreme Court

The highest court in Alabama, the Supreme Court, doesn’t automatically hear all appeals. Instead, you must file a petition for a writ of certiorari asking the court to review your case. The Supreme Court typically only agrees to hear cases that involve significant questions of law or matters of great public importance.

❖ Federal Habeas Corpus

If you’ve exhausted your state appeals, you may have the option to file a federal habeas corpus petition. This is a complex area of law with strict time limits and procedural requirements. It allows federal courts to review state convictions for violations of federal constitutional rights.

Protect Your Rights: Contact our Seasoned Auburn, AL Criminal Defense Attorneys

If you are considering a criminal appeal in Alabama, don’t face this daunting process alone. Our experienced attorneys at Alsobrook Law Group are here to guide you through every step of the appeals process, fighting hard to protect your rights and seek the justice you deserve. Contact us today for a confidential consultation and case assessment.

Share this entry
Zachary D. Alsobrook

Zach Alsobrook

ATTORNEY AT LAW

Zachary D. Alsobrook is a partner in the Opelika law firm of Alsobrook Law Group, where he concentrates his practice in the areas of criminal defense and DUI; divorce, child custody…

Practice Areas