Contempt of Court Divorce Attorneys Auburn, AL

What Is Contempt of Court in an Auburn, AL Divorce Case?

Receiving your final divorce decree in Alabama often brings a sense of closure, but it’s not uncommon for one party to ignore their court-ordered obligations. This non-compliance can lead to contempt of court proceedings, a legal mechanism designed to enforce compliance and uphold the authority of the court. In Alabama, contempt of court typically involves willful disobedience of a lawful court order, such as failing to pay child support or violating custody agreements, and can result in fines, imprisonment, or other penalties.

Types of Contempt in Alabama

Alabama law, primarily guided by Rule 70A of the Alabama Rules of Civil Procedure, recognizes different types of contempt, with civil and criminal contempt being the most relevant distinctions in the divorce context.

Civil Contempt

The overwhelming majority of contempt actions related to divorce decrees fall under civil contempt.

Purpose: The primary goal of civil contempt is coercive and remedial. It’s designed to compel the non-compliant party (the “contemnor”) to obey the court order for the benefit of the aggrieved party (the “movant” or “petitioner”). It aims to fix the problem and secure future compliance.
“Keys to the Jail Cell”: A common characteristic of coercive civil contempt, especially when jail time is imposed, is the inclusion of a “purge clause.” This means the contemnor holds the power to secure their own release by performing the required act (e.g., paying a specified portion of child support arrears, signing a property deed). They metaphorically hold the keys to their own jail cell – compliance unlocks the door.
Burden of Proof: The standard of proof for civil contempt in Alabama is typically “clear and convincing evidence,” which is a higher standard than a mere preponderance of the evidence but lower than the criminal standard.

Criminal Contempt

While less common in typical divorce enforcement, criminal contempt can arise, particularly in cases of severe or repeated defiance, or actions that directly insult the court’s dignity.

Purpose: Criminal contempt is primarily punitive. Its goal is to punish the contemnor for past willful disobedience and to vindicate the authority of the court itself. The punishment is typically a fixed term of imprisonment or a fine, payable to the court, not the aggrieved party.
Penalties: Penalties for criminal contempt are distinct from civil remedies. They don’t necessarily aim to compel future compliance but rather to punish the past offense. Because it involves potential loss of liberty as punishment, the proceedings require greater procedural safeguards.
Burden of Proof: Due to the punitive nature and potential for imprisonment as punishment (not coercion), criminal contempt requires proof “beyond a reasonable doubt,” the same high standard used in criminal prosecutions.

In most Auburn, AL divorce enforcement situations, the focus will be on civil contempt remedies aimed at getting the other party to follow the existing order.

Common Examples of Contempt in Divorce Cases

In most Auburn, AL divorce enforcement situations, the focus will be on civil contempt remedies aimed at getting the other party to follow the existing order.

Failure to Pay Child Support or Alimony

This is perhaps the most common reason for contempt filings. It includes not paying the full amount, paying sporadically or late, failing to contribute to agreed-upon expenses like medical bills, childcare, or extracurricular activities, or not maintaining required life insurance to secure support. Consistent failure to meet these financial obligations places significant strain on the receiving parent and the children.

Violation of Child Custody or Visitation Agreements

Non-compliance with parenting plans can cause emotional distress for both parents and children. Examples include:

Consistently denying the other parent their scheduled parenting time without a valid reason.
Refusing to return the child at the agreed-upon time.
Interfering with communication (phone calls, video chats) between the child and the other parent.
Making important decisions about the child’s health, education, or religion unilaterally when joint legal custody requires consultation.
Relocating with the child in violation of the decree or Alabama’s relocation statute.
Disparaging the other parent in front of the children in a way that undermines the relationship (sometimes linked to contempt findings).

Refusal to Transfer or Divide Property

Divorce decrees often mandate specific actions regarding marital assets and debts. Contempt can occur if a party fails to:

Sign over the title to a vehicle or execute a deed (like a Quitclaim Deed) transferring ownership of real estate awarded to the ex-spouse.
Refinance a mortgage to remove the other party’s name from the liability.
Cooperate in selling the marital home or other assets as ordered.
Divide funds into bank accounts or investment accounts according to the decree.
Take necessary steps to divide retirement assets, such as executing a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO).

Non-Compliance with Debt Obligations

If the decree assigns certain marital debts to one party, their failure to pay those debts can harm the other party’s credit rating, potentially leading to a contempt action seeking indemnification or enforcement.

Failure to Provide Financial Disclosure

Although more common during the divorce process, ongoing obligations for financial disclosure (e.g., exchanging tax returns annually if required for support calculations) can also lead to contempt if ignored.

Any willful failure to adhere to a clear provision in your Lee County divorce decree could be grounds for a contempt action.

The Contempt of Court Process in Alabama (The Rule Nisi Path)

If your ex-spouse is violating your divorce decree, you must seek enforcement through the court system. In Alabama, this often involves initiating contempt proceedings, frequently via a “Petition for Rule Nisi.” Here’s a more detailed look at the typical steps in Lee County Circuit Court:

Failure to Provide Financial Disclosure

The process begins when the aggrieved party (the Petitioner) files a “Verified Petition for Rule Nisi” or “Motion for Contempt” with the Clerk of the Lee County Circuit Court. “Verified” means the Petitioner signs the document under oath, attesting to the truthfulness of the statements within it. This petition must clearly identify:

The specific court order (usually the divorce decree) being violated.
The specific provisions of the order that have been disobeyed.
Detailed facts describing how and when the Respondent violated the order (dates, amounts unpaid, instances of denied visitation, etc.).
A statement that the Respondent’s violation was willful.
The specific relief being requested from the court (e.g., finding the Respondent in contempt, ordering payment of arrears, awarding make-up visitation, granting attorney fees).

Required Documentation

Supporting documentation is often attached to the petition, such as:

A copy of the relevant court order (the divorce decree).
Financial records (spreadsheets of unpaid support, bank statements).
Communication records (emails, texts showing denial of visitation or refusal to comply).
Affidavits from witnesses, if applicable.

Issuance of the Rule Nisi / Show Cause Order

Upon reviewing the petition, if it appears legally sufficient, the judge will typically issue a “Rule Nisi” or “Order to Show Cause.” This court order commands the Respondent to appear in court at a specified date and time to explain why they should not be held in contempt for the alleged violations. It sets the stage for the hearing.

Proper Service

Critically, the Respondent must be legally served with a copy of the Petition and the Rule Nisi/Show Cause Order. This ensures they have adequate notice of the allegations and the hearing date, fulfilling constitutional due process requirements. Service might be accomplished by certified mail, a sheriff’s deputy, or a private process server. Failure to achieve proper service can halt the proceedings.

The Contempt Hearing (Show Cause Hearing)

This is the core of the process. Both parties, along with their attorneys (if represented), appear before the judge.

The Petitioner presents their case first, offering evidence (documents, testimony from themselves and potentially witnesses) to establish the elements of contempt: the existence of a clear order, the Respondent’s knowledge of the order, and the Respondent’s willful failure to comply.
The Respondent then has the opportunity to present their defense, offering their own testimony, witnesses, and documents to refute the allegations or establish a valid defense (like inability to pay or ambiguity in the order).
Both sides can cross-examine witnesses.
The judge listens to the evidence, assesses the credibility of the parties and witnesses, and considers legal arguments. The judge’s role is pivotal in determining whether the non-compliance was willful.

Court's Ruling and Order

After the hearing, the judge will issue a ruling. They may rule immediately from the bench or take the matter under advisement and issue a written order later. The order will state whether the Respondent is found in contempt. If contempt is found, the order will detail the specific sanctions and remedies imposed, including any purge conditions necessary to avoid penalties like jail time. If contempt is not found, the petition will be dismissed.

Potential Consequences of Contempt

Being found in contempt of court in an Alabama divorce case is a serious matter with significant potential consequences designed to compel compliance and penalize willful disobedience. A Lee County judge has considerable discretion but may impose one or more of the following:

1. Incarceration (Jail Time):

As noted, this is often coercive in civil contempt. The judge might sentence the contemnor to jail until they comply with the purge clause (e.g., pay $X amount of support). Punitive sentences (fixed terms) are possible but require higher standards.

2. Fines:

Monetary penalties may be levied, either payable to the court or sometimes directed to the aggrieved party as compensation.

3. Wage Garnishment / Income Withholding:

Especially for failure to pay child support or alimony, the court can order the contemnor’s employer to withhold payments directly from their wages.

4. Payment of Attorney’s Fees and Costs:

Alabama courts frequently order the party found in contempt to pay the reasonable attorney fees and court costs incurred by the compliant party in bringing the enforcement action. This prevents the compliant party from being penalized financially for seeking enforcement.

5. Modification of Custody or Visitation Orders:

While contempt itself doesn’t automatically change custody, a pattern of willful non-compliance, especially regarding visitation or decisions impacting the child’s welfare, can be presented as evidence supporting a separate request to modify the underlying custody or visitation order, arguing it’s in the child’s best interest due to the contemnor’s disregard for court orders or parental responsibilities.

6. Make-Up Parenting Time:

If visitation was wrongfully denied, the court will likely order specific make-up days or weekends.

7. Specific Performance Orders:

Forcing the contemnor to take a specific action, like signing a deed, cooperating with a QDRO administrator, or facilitating the sale of property.

8. Seizure of Assets/Liens:

In some cases, the court might authorize placing a lien on property or seizing assets (like bank accounts) to satisfy monetary obligations.

9. License Suspension/Passport Denial:

Particularly for significant child support arrears, driver’s, professional, and recreational licenses can be suspended under Alabama law, and federal actions like passport denial can occur.

The specific consequences depend heavily on the nature and severity of the violation, the contemnor’s history of compliance, and the evidence presented.

Preventing Contempt Issues

While contempt proceedings provide a remedy for non-compliance, the ideal scenario is to avoid such conflicts altogether. Proactive steps and clear communication can significantly reduce the risk of contempt issues arising after your divorce:

1. Thoroughly Understand Your Decree:

Read your entire divorce decree carefully. If any part is unclear, seek clarification before issues arise, perhaps through your attorney or even a joint motion for clarification if needed. Make notes of deadlines and specific obligations.

2. Maintain Meticulous Records:

Keep detailed records of all payments made (child support, alimony), visitation exchanges (dates, times, any issues), communication regarding co-parenting decisions, and property transfers. This documentation is invaluable if compliance is ever questioned.

3. Communicate Respectfully (and Document It):

While communication with an ex-spouse can be difficult, strive for respectful, business-like interactions, especially regarding children. Use written communication (email, co-parenting apps) for important matters, as this creates a record. Avoid hostile or inflammatory language.

4. Address Changed Circumstances Proactively:

Life changes. If you experience a significant change in circumstances (job loss, income reduction, serious illness) that affects your ability to comply with the order (especially regarding support payments), don’t just stop complying. Immediately consult with an attorney about filing a Petition to Modify the order based on the changed circumstances. Waiting until you’re facing contempt charges weakens your position.

5. Follow the Order, Even If You Disagree:

Unless there’s an immediate safety risk (especially concerning children), you must follow the court order as written. If you believe the order is unfair or needs changing, the proper route is to file for a modification, not to engage in self-help by violating it.

6. Consider Mediation for Minor Disputes:

For disagreements that don’t necessarily warrant immediate court action, mediation might help resolve issues before they escalate to contempt levels.

Taking these preventative measures can save significant time, expense, and emotional distress down the road.

Work with Our Seasoned Auburn, AL Family Law Attorneys

Whether your ex-spouse is failing to pay support, denying visitation, or refusing to follow property division terms, or if you’ve been served with contempt papers yourself, don’t delay. The Alsobrook Law Group attorneys are dedicated to helping clients in Auburn and throughout Lee County navigate challenging issues such as contempt of court in civil cases like divorce. We understand the frustration and anxiety these situations cause and are committed to providing knowledgeable, effective representation.

Zach Alsobrook

ATTORNEY AT LAW

Zachary D. Alsobrook is a partner in the Opelika law firm of Alsobrook Law Group, where he concentrates his practice in the areas of criminal defense and DUI; divorce, child custody…

Contempt of Court Divorce Attorneys Auburn, AL

What Is Contempt of Court in an Auburn, AL Divorce Case?

Types of Contempt in Alabama

Civil Contempt

Criminal Contempt

Common Examples of Contempt in Divorce Cases

Failure to Pay Child Support or Alimony

Violation of Child Custody or Visitation Agreements

Refusal to Transfer or Divide Property

Non-Compliance with Debt Obligations

Failure to Provide Financial Disclosure

The Contempt of Court Process in Alabama (The Rule Nisi Path)

Failure to Provide Financial Disclosure

Required Documentation

Issuance of the Rule Nisi / Show Cause Order

Proper Service

The Contempt Hearing (Show Cause Hearing)

Court's Ruling and Order

Potential Consequences of Contempt

1. Incarceration (Jail Time):

2. Fines:

3. Wage Garnishment / Income Withholding:

4. Payment of Attorney’s Fees and Costs:

5. Modification of Custody or Visitation Orders:

6. Make-Up Parenting Time:

7. Specific Performance Orders:

8. Seizure of Assets/Liens:

9. License Suspension/Passport Denial:

Preventing Contempt Issues

1. Thoroughly Understand Your Decree:

2. Maintain Meticulous Records:

3. Communicate Respectfully (and Document It):

4. Address Changed Circumstances Proactively:

5. Follow the Order, Even If You Disagree:

6. Consider Mediation for Minor Disputes:

Work with Our Seasoned Auburn, AL Family Law Attorneys

Zach Alsobrook

ATTORNEY AT LAW

Practice Areas

Firm Location

Quicklinks

Practice Areas

Connect With Us